Black-Scholes and Black-76 for Indian options
Which model fits NIFTY, BANK NIFTY and SENSEX options and which fits MCX options on gold futures, what each input means, worked prices and where they break.
- By
- Veloce team
- Published
- Reading time
- 9 min read
On this page
Black-Scholes prices a European option on an asset with a spot price, such as an index, allowing for the interest rate and the asset’s dividend yield. Black-76 prices a European option on a futures contract, using the futures price directly with no carry term. In India, NIFTY, BANK NIFTY and SENSEX options are European and cash-settled against the index, so Black-Scholes with a dividend yield fits them. MCX gold options are written on gold futures, so Black-76 fits them. The two are the same formula with a different forward: give Black-76 the index’s forward for the option’s expiry and it returns the same price as Black-Scholes. This article sets out the formula, explains each input, prices a NIFTY weekly and an MCX gold option with Veloce’s pricing code, shows what goes wrong when the models are swapped, and lists the model’s limits.
Market inputs are illustrative. Nothing here is a recommendation.
One formula, two forwards
Both models price a call and a put from the forward price F of the underlying at expiry:
- Call = e^(−rT) × [F × N(d1) − K × N(d2)]
- Put = e^(−rT) × [K × N(−d2) − F × N(−d1)]
- d1 = [ln(F / K) + σ²T / 2] / (σ√T), and d2 = d1 − σ√T
where K is the strike, T the time to expiry in years, r the risk-free rate, σ the volatility, and N the standard normal distribution. Everything is in continuous compounding.
The models differ only in how they get F:
| Model | Underlying | Forward | Cost of carry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Black-Scholes (with dividend yield) | Spot index S | F = S × e^((r − q)T) | r − q |
| Black-76 | Futures price F | F as quoted | 0 |
This is exactly how Veloce’s pricing code is written: one generalised formula with a pluggable model that supplies the cost of carry. Black-Scholes supplies r − q; Black-76 supplies zero, because the futures price already includes the carry.
The inputs, one by one
| Input | What to use | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Underlying | Index level (Black-Scholes) or futures price (Black-76) | Use a price from the same moment as the option price |
| Strike | The contract’s strike | NIFTY strikes are 50 points apart |
| Time to expiry | Years until the settlement moment | Veloce counts calendar time to the second over a 365-day year |
| Rate | Short-term rupee rate, continuously compounded | India VIX uses NSE MIBOR at the matching tenor (NSE) |
| Dividend yield | The index’s expected yield, continuous | Black-Scholes only |
| Volatility | Implied volatility, or the one you want to test | The only input not observable directly |
Time to expiry deserves care for weekly options. NIFTY weekly options settle at the close of the NSE derivatives session on expiry day, which has been 15:40 since August 3, 2026. From 10:00 on Wednesday, November 25, 2026, to 15:40 on Tuesday, December 1, 2026, is 6 days, 5 hours and 40 minutes: 0.017085 years. Rounding that to “6 days” knocks about 2% off an at-the-money price. On expiry day, every hour is a large share of what is left.
A day-count note. Counting calendar days means weekends and holidays decay the option like any other day. Some traders prefer trading-day or trading-hour clocks. Either is defensible; what matters is using the same clock to solve implied volatility and to price, so that the model returns the market price it was calibrated to.
A worked NIFTY example
Illustrative inputs: NIFTY at 26,000, the 26,000 call and put on the weekly expiring December 1, 2026, valued at 10:00 on November 25, 2026, rate 6.5%, dividend yield 1.2%, IV 12%.
The forward is 26,000 × e^((0.065 − 0.012) × 0.017085) = 26,023.55. With it:
| Model and inputs | 26,000 call | Delta | Theta/day | Rho/pt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black-Scholes, q = 1.2% | 174.62 | 0.5260 | −14.97 | 2.31 |
| Black-Scholes, q = 0 | 177.44 | 0.5313 | −15.43 | 2.33 |
| Black-76 on F = 26,023.55 | 174.62 | 0.5256 | −12.98 | −0.03 |
Three things stand out:
- The dividend yield matters. Ignoring it adds ₹2.82 to the call. On a weekly option that is small; on a monthly it is larger, and it is systematic, so a model without it will imply the wrong IV from every price.
- Black-76 on the right forward gives the same price. Price is price. If a NIFTY future for the same expiry existed and traded at the model forward, Black-76 on it would agree with Black-Scholes on spot.
- The greeks differ, because the question differs. Black-Scholes delta is per point of spot; Black-76 delta is per point of the forward. Black-Scholes theta holds spot fixed as time passes, so the forward drifts towards spot; Black-76 theta holds the forward fixed. Black-76 rho holds the forward fixed, so only discounting moves. None of these is wrong. Use the greeks of the model whose underlying you actually hedge with.
Where to get the forward for a weekly. NIFTY futures are listed for monthly expiries (NSE contract specifications), so a weekly option has no future of its own expiry. The common workaround is to imply the forward from the at-the-money call and put using put-call parity: F = K + (C − P) × e^(rT). That folds the rate and dividend assumptions into one number the market sets. The put-call parity guide works through it.
A worked MCX gold example
MCX lists options on its gold futures. The underlying of a GOLD option is the GOLD futures contract, not spot gold, and the option’s lot is the futures lot: 1 kg, with prices quoted per 10 grams, so 100 price units per lot (MCX: GOLD). The options expire before their underlying futures, and an in-the-money option devolves into a position in that futures contract rather than settling in cash. MCX revises expiry dates by circular, so check the current ones (MCX circulars).
Illustrative inputs: GOLD futures at ₹1,20,000 per 10 grams, 33 days to the option’s expiry (0.0904 years), rate 6.5%, IV 16%. With Black-76:
| Strike | Call | Put | Call delta | Put delta |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,18,000 | 3,401.62 | 1,413.33 | 0.6418 | −0.3523 |
| 1,20,000 | 2,289.43 | 2,289.43 | 0.5066 | −0.4875 |
| 1,22,000 | 1,449.27 | 3,437.55 | 0.3725 | −0.6217 |
At the money, the call and put have the same price. That is Black-76’s version of put-call parity: with no carry, the forward is the futures price, so C − P = e^(−rT) × (F − K), which is zero when F = K. Per lot, the at-the-money call’s ₹2,289.43 per 10 grams is 2,289.43 × 100 = ₹2,28,943.
What happens if you use Black-Scholes on the futures price. Treating ₹1,20,000 as a spot price with no dividend adds the interest rate as carry, so the model’s forward becomes 1,20,000 × e^(0.065 × 0.0904), about ₹1,20,707, which double-counts the carry the futures price already contains:
| 1,20,000 strike, IV 16% | Black-76 (correct) | Black-Scholes on futures (wrong) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Call | 2,289.43 | 2,664.85 | +375.42 (+16.4%) |
| Put | 2,289.43 | 1,961.72 | −327.71 (−14.3%) |
Run it the other way and the error lands in implied volatility. An at-the-money call trading at ₹2,200 implies 15.37% under Black-76 and 12.73% under the wrong model: a 2.6-point error, in a different direction for calls and puts. This is the most common mistake people make when they reuse an index options calculator for commodity options.
Input mistakes and what they cost
Most wrong model prices come from the inputs, not the formula. Using the NIFTY example above, where the correct 26,000 call price is 174.62:
| Mistake | What the model returns | Error |
|---|---|---|
| Time rounded down to 6 whole days | 171.06 | −3.56 |
| Time rounded up to 7 days | 185.77 | +11.15 |
| 6 days divided by 252 instead of 365 | 208.72 | +34.10 |
| Rate left at zero (dividend yield kept) | 160.03 | −14.59 |
| Dividend yield left at zero | 177.44 | +2.82 |
The worst error in the table comes from mixing clocks: dividing calendar days by 252, a trading-day year, gives the option about 40% more time than it has, and inflates the price by a fifth. A trading-day clock is fine if you use it everywhere, including when you solve IV; mixed with a calendar-day IV, it is simply wrong.
Leaving the rate at zero hurts more than its small rho suggests, because the error is the whole rate, 6.5 points, not a fraction of one. With no rate but a dividend yield, the model’s forward falls below spot, so calls come out too cheap and puts too dear: the put is 165.36 instead of 151.09.
A quick check catches most of these: price the call and the put at the same strike and confirm that C − P equals S × e^(−qT) − K × e^(−rT). If your inputs imply a forward far from where the market’s call and put prices put it, one of the inputs is off.
Where the models break
Black-Scholes and Black-76 rest on the same assumptions, and real markets break all of them.
- Constant volatility. The model has one σ for every strike and every moment. Market prices imply different volatilities by strike (the smile and skew) and by expiry, and IV moves every minute. Traders use the model as a translation between price and IV rather than as a description of the market. See implied volatility explained.
- Lognormal returns. The model assumes moves of a given size are as likely as a bell curve says. Index returns have fatter tails, and gaps happen: NIFTY can open hundreds of points away from the previous close. Out-of-the-money options price that in with higher IVs.
- Continuous trading and hedging. The model’s price is what it costs to hedge continuously with no costs. In practice hedging is discrete, slips, and pays STT, exchange charges and GST on every trade (F&O charges explained).
- Known, constant rates and dividends. NIFTY dividends arrive in lumps, concentrated in some months; a single yield smooths them out. Rates change, though for weekly options rho is too small for this to matter much.
- European exercise. Index options in India are European, so this fits. It would not fit an American option, where early exercise has value.
- Settlement details. NSE and BSE index options settle in cash on the index’s closing value on expiry day; MCX gold options devolve into futures. The model’s payoff is the same formula, but the practical consequences (cash versus a futures position and its margin) are not.
How Veloce uses these models
Veloce’s backtests do not price options with a model. They replay the recorded one-minute prices of the actual NIFTY, BANK NIFTY and SENSEX contracts a strategy would have traded, fill at the next candle’s open, and charge every fill. The market’s smile, skew and fat tails are already in those prices, so none of the limits above leak into a backtest’s P&L.
The models are for analysis: implied volatility, greeks, and what a position might be worth at a later date or a different IV. Veloce’s pricing API accepts "model": "black-scholes" (with an optional dividend yield) for index options and "model": "black-76" for options on futures. Veloce backtests MCX gold and gold mini futures, not gold options.
Try it in Veloce
Veloce backtests NSE NIFTY and BANK NIFTY options, BSE SENSEX options and MCX gold futures on one-minute data. The NSE index options page, SENSEX options page and MCX gold futures page list the contract details Veloce uses; NIFTY lots are 65 units for weekly contracts expiring from January 6, 2026 (NSE/FAOP/70616).
POST /api/analytics/payoff and POST /api/analytics/iv expose the pricing code described here. Coming soon: an option chain and analytics screen in the app for prices, IV and greeks.
Create a free Veloce account and backtest a strategy on recorded prices. For the greeks these models produce, see option greeks explained; for gold contracts, see MCX gold vs gold mini futures.
Frequently asked questions
- Which model should I use for NIFTY options?
- NIFTY, BANK NIFTY and SENSEX options are European and cash-settled against the index, so Black-Scholes with a dividend yield fits. Black-76 on the forward for the same expiry gives exactly the same price; the two differ only in what you treat as the underlying.
- Why are MCX gold options priced with Black-76?
- Because the underlying is a gold futures contract, not spot gold. A futures price already includes the cost of carry, so Black-76 uses it directly with no carry term. Using Black-Scholes on the futures price as if it were spot overprices calls and underprices puts.
- What risk-free rate should I use?
- A short-term rupee rate for a tenor near the option's expiry, converted to continuous compounding. NSE's India VIX uses NSE MIBOR at the matching tenor. Small differences between candidate rates matter little for weekly options, about Rs 2.31 per point of rate on an at-the-money NIFTY weekly in our example, but leaving the rate out entirely moves the price by about Rs 14.60.
- What dividend yield should I use for NIFTY?
- The index's expected dividend yield over the option's life, as a continuous annual rate. It lowers the forward and so lowers call prices. In our example a 1.2% yield cuts the at-the-money weekly call from 177.44 to 174.62. Alternatively, back the forward out of call and put prices with put-call parity.
- Is Black-Scholes accurate for Indian options?
- It is a consistent way to convert between price and implied volatility, which is how traders use it. As a forecast it is wrong in known ways: real returns have fat tails and jumps, volatility changes, and different strikes trade at different implied volatilities.
- Can Veloce backtest MCX gold options?
- No. Veloce backtests MCX gold and gold mini futures, and NSE and BSE index options. Its pricing API supports Black-76, so you can price options on futures, but gold options are not part of backtesting.
Sources
- Black, F. and Scholes, M. (1973): The pricing of options and corporate liabilities, Journal of Political Economy 81(3)doi.org, accessed
- Black, F. (1976): The pricing of commodity contracts, Journal of Financial Economics 3(1-2)doi.org, accessed
- MCX: GOLD contract specificationsmcxindia.com, accessed
- MCX circulars MCX/TRD/081/2026 and MCX/TRD/082/2026: revision in expiry dates of futures and options contracts (20 February 2026)mcxindia.com, accessed
- NSE: equity derivatives contract specificationsnseindia.com, accessed
- NSE: India VIX (computation methodology and white paper)nseindia.com, accessed
- NSE circular NSE/FAOP/70616: revision in market lot of derivative contracts on indices (October 3, 2025)nsearchives.nseindia.com, accessed